Bogomil ShopovVia different channels I got the same question :
Did you get your 5 dollars back?
It’s not a secret, that I got this question as well:
Did you really delete the data as requested? Can you sell it to me … /can you share it with me?/
Well the truth is, I don’t want my 5$ back, especially not from Facebook.
And yes, I deleted the data…but maybe, just maybe I’ve deleted the data the same way Facebook deletes users’ data when he/she wants to delete his/her account…
What do I want?
[box color=”red”]
I want Facebook to start removing entire user data after pressing “Delete my account”. Is this so much to ask. This is fair, isn’t it? Can we achieve that as a community?
[/box]
Do you have a copy of that list? can you sell to me
Welcome to the cyberverse of Facebook, you can check out any time you like- but you can never leave!
Getting Farcebook to delete all traces of your account is harder than pulling an ingrowing hair out of a crocodile’s arse!
What I found interesting when I found this information/news on some sites and pressed share on FB it said there was an error. Hmmm I link stuff everyday via FB, seems something is wrong with my ” LINKER” when it came to this information.
You got a good point, If you want to delete all your data from anywhere you should be able to.
I have tried to delete my Facebook account 3 times now with no success whatsoever. After submitting the “DELETE(not deactivating it) MY ACCOUNT request” and waited for over a month every time I go back to check if the account has been delete expecting to receive an “invalid username or password” what I always get is a F@#$%ing welcome back we have activated your account again.
Part of the problem isn’t what Facebook chooses to actually delete when a user selects to “Delete my account”, but rather what is technically feasible.
Facebook’s architecture is built for scalability and performance, not for traceability of data or audit capabilities. The fact is, to achieve that scalability and performance, it means keeping many copies of your data on many machines, all using different software and infrastructure. Some are used to serve the website, some for API access. There are 10’s of thousands of database servers, just as many caching servers, and even more web application servers. There’s also back-end analytics servers which use algorithms to work your social graph to show recommended friends, highlighted posts, ads, internal Facebook stuff and much more. There are dozens of software and hardware layers your data flows through, all which have hard drives and local memory to store whatever data they need to do their job(s). Data is also chopped up into smaller, more manageable “shards” since the whole Facebook social graph and all it’s accompanying data is extremely large and too big to fit on any one machine or hard drive. So, finding all your shards, copies, backups for all of your data on all machines would be a very difficult task – perhaps today it would be impossible for them. This is the kind of core feature that needs to be integrated into the system right from the start. It’s unfortunate they strategically seem focused on more user-facing features instead of spending the necessary effort to get better at privacy.
I am not condoning what Facebook does. Nor am I debating what the “Delete my account” functionality means to a user (not to Facebook) to actually remove all user data and not keep “some” anonymized data for whatever purposes. I’m just noting that technically it’s very complex and would be a significant effort/cost to add the capabilities necessary to ensure all data was truly deleted. Note that this problem is faced by the Google’s, Apple’s and other large tech companies too, not just Facebook. Some are better at it than others, but it’s the nature of the “cloud.”
@Tomer – unfortunately selling user data to third parties is how a majority of internet-based companies make money. It’s just the nature of an industry which provides free ad supported services. I do agree we need better controls around these as users, such as opt-in/out options and clarity (in plain non-legalese language) of terms. There are efforts working towards this – lets hope they make progress!
Well, I’m just asking… Could you tell us why you wanted to buy that pack from a Facebook application? And then, if it was exactly what you were looking for: As a costumer, I know I would be pleased to see I can get such an awesome product 4 just a few dollars.
I ‘m really surprised after reading all the Facebook threats, and the way they want to keep ur silence. But I’m actually shocked for what U did at first.
So: Why don’t you tell us the reason why you bought all that information?
Just to prove what Policy is able to do in extreme terms?
How would we know for sure that Facecrook really deleted our data anyway? They could say they did, but then their definition of “deleted” means sold to some guy in Bulgaria for $2.50.
A very reasonable request.
This could be a gold mine :D…
Is it possible to get some money from them, like suing them…for having our info on the wild?
5 dollars?? 5 million dollars that would be a begining… incompetents…
I can’t agree more. I wanted Facebook to remove all my data, but was never able to. They would constantly send me emails, and ask me to reactivate my account every time I visit facebook.com.
I had to remove all cookies, change all my information on their website, and mark any message from Facebook as spam to stop this. Can’t they understand that not everyone on earth wants to spend all their time on their website.
You all have a misunderstood concept of facebook, how do you guys think Facebook make all of their millions? just on advertisments? If you are not paying for a product, you are the product. And facebook is in for a big business, so is google. So lets stop being “so surprise” I don’t like the way they try to play innocent either, but should we play innoncent too?
I think you are scared
Facebook and other social networking sites will NEVER delete data (on purpose). They will take the ‘deleted’ data ‘off-line’, but it is never gone.
Well folks you were warned.fb is big brother period.
No.
Facebook owns your data.
Go take a hike.
I’d like Facebook to not collect data from users that don’t volunteer it. Is that to much to request?
I would like Facebook to ask me if I want them to delete my info when I press “delete my account”
Exact reason why we no longer use Facebook.
I deleted my account 2 years ago and still recieve newsletters, notifications, friend requests on my email. But can’t login with that email. WTF!?
@tomer If it’s sensitive, why did you put it on Facebook?
I’d like people to start taking responsibility for their own actions, including agreeing to draconian policies which stand as guards to corporate services.
I’d like people to understand that working collaboratively, a la OSS and the Creative Commons will take us light years ahead of the old ways of working.
I’d like people to learn to embrace the difficult parts of life as opposed to running away from them and “letting somebody else think about it”.
We can only dream, eh?
Even I’d want facebook to remove entire data when I hit “Delete My Account”.
A very good and fair point!
Like any other company these days…whach what you share, because it can be dangerous to use from bad people in some cases
I’d like Facebook not to share sensitive user data with 3rd parties. Is it too much to request?
WTF does everybody think internet corporations are charities?
Of course they will sell user data if they can earn from it and of course 99 percent of the users will just click that they agree with everything without even reading the Eula.
If it is confidential don’t put it on Facebook, better don’t put it on the internet at all.